Practice Forward with XcelLabs
While more individuals are adopting AI to seek advice, make decisions, and explore ideas, accounting firms are overwhelmingly using it as an automation engine. This means firms aren't leveraging the creative, advisory, and strategic areas open to them via AI.
The accounting profession is caught in a paradox. News and examples of advanced AI use are everywhere, yet the profession is not leveraging AI beyond basic automation.
OpenAI reports that 73% of ChatGPT usage is for personal, nonwork tasks, up from 53% the previous year. Businesses, on the other hand, are routing 77% of their Claude API AI activity into task automation, not collaboration or creative problem-solving. This represents a lot of missed opportunities.
For accounting professionals, these numbers demand attention. AI shouldn’t be isolated into simply automating traditional workflows and crunching numbers faster. The deeper power of AI can transform firms via collaboration and forward thinking. It’s about using AI to make firms better, not just faster.
The Great Divide
The most telling insight from the reports mentioned above is that while more individuals are adopting AI to seek advice, make decisions, and explore ideas, businesses are overwhelmingly focused on AI as an automation engine only. This means firms are relying on AI to hand off repeatable tasks while the creative, advisory, and strategic areas remain isolated from meaningful AI support.
Let’s break down the difference in personal and work use a bit more:
-
Personal use: The leading AI use case at home is practical guidance. This includes learning new skills, planning workouts or meals, and solving personal challenges. AI is being put to the test to help lower friction and make our personal lives better.
-
Work use: In-office use is mostly limited to automation, such as coding, scheduling, and admin tasks. There is little experimentation or partnership in decision-making. An automation-first mindset, while efficient for rote processes, often sidelines AI from the collaborative advisory work where it can deliver the greatest value.
Why is there a divide? Well, here are a few big ones:
At Home
-
No one is watching how you prompt.
-
You don't need permission to try something new.
-
Every success directly benefits you, whether it is a refined workout routine, a new household budget, or an enhanced nutrition plan.
-
There’s no “right way” to prompt holding you back from being creative.
At Work
-
People worry about looking incompetent, so they keep prompts simple and focused on basic automation.
-
There are IT restrictions and tool limitations.
-
The expectations about when/how to use AI are unclear.
-
Many fear that using AI threatens their expertise.
Simply put, AI use in the professional setting appears to be a behavior issue rather than a technical problem.
The Barriers – And Why They Matter
The accounting profession faces key barriers to full AI adoption, including:
The automation trap – Too many firms see AI as a vending machine: input task, get output, move on. This works for narrow use cases, but it's not where future-ready client service or firm strategy is created. Accountants using AI at home treat it as a brainstorming partner, not just a replacement for manual labor. Firms must unlock this same dynamic at work, inviting AI into planning, advisory, and client strategy sessions.
Incentive misalignment – At home, AI directly benefits the individual. At work, ambiguity is in play. Will using AI make me look replaceable? Is mastery of AI tools valued or quietly discouraged? Until leaders unequivocally signal that AI proficiency is a career must-have, not a threat, accounting pros will continue to hesitate.
The behavior gap – This isn’t a technology problem. It’s a daily habit problem. Accountants are great at their jobs, so the instinct to ask AI for support simply hasn’t taken root. Building new routines, like consulting AI for that thorny client question or using it to debrief after a tough meeting, requires intentional practice. Try using it for just one task, every day, until it feels as natural as launching Excel.
The Way Forward
While there is no silver bullet for full adoption, there is a clear way ahead for accounting leaders and their teams:
-
Lower the friction – Allow safe, permission-free AI experimentation inside the firm. The same curiosity professionals show at home needs to be welcomed and rewarded at work.
-
Align the incentives – Explicitly recognize and reward AI proficiency. Tie it to advancement, bonuses, and high-value client work. Make it part of the firm's DNA.
-
Build the habit – Shift from aspiration to routine. One meaningful use of AI every day grows into new instincts, better questions, and, ultimately, more valuable client outcomes.
This isn’t about a technology adoption for its own sake; it’s about making AI a partner in the pursuit of smarter leadership, better advisory, and deeper human connection.
For firms and practitioners willing to close the divide, the next leap in advisory excellence is just one new habit away.
Want to learn more? Join Jody Padar on March 4 for a free webinar, “Becoming a More Human Advisor in an AI World.” See what it means to actually work with AI in your day-to-day as a CPA.
Jody Padar, CPA, also known as “The Radical CPA,” is the co-founder of XcelLabs, a training and technology platform that offers solutions to help accountants use AI to build fluency and strategic thinking. Contact XcelLabs for more information.
Backed by the PICPA, XcelLabs is helping CPAs leverage AI to expand advisory capabilities, strengthen firms, and keep the profession future-ready.
Sign up for PICPA's weekly professional and technical updates by completing this form.
Statements of fact and opinion are the author's responsibility alone and do not imply an opinion on the part of the PICPA's officers or members. The information contained herein does not constitute accounting, legal, or professional advice. For actionable advice, you must engage or consult with a qualified professional.
